The 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has revived a New Hampshire resident’s challenge to a federal firearm restriction based on two Massachusetts drunken-driving convictions from 1997 and 2005.
A three-judge panel on Friday vacated the dismissal of the lawsuit and sent the case forward. The opinion was written by Chief Judge David Barron and joined by Circuit Judges Sandra Lynch and Lara Montecalvo.
The case concerns the application of 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), a federal law that generally bars people convicted of crimes punishable by more than one year in prison from possessing or receiving firearms. The resident’s Massachusetts convictions involved driving under the influence. Although the offenses were misdemeanors, Massachusetts law allows a sentence of up to 2½ years, placing them above the federal threshold described in the ruling.
Background of the lawsuit
After moving to New Hampshire in 2023, the resident applied to buy a handgun and a long gun for home defense. An FBI background check flagged the old Massachusetts convictions as “federal disqualifier(s),” and the New Hampshire State Police Permits and Licensing Unit rejected the application.
The resident filed the federal lawsuit in June 2024, naming Attorney General Todd Blanche, FBI Director Kashyap Pramod Patel and ATF Director Robert Cekada as defendants. The lawsuit asks the court to prevent the federal government from enforcing the firearm prohibition against him.
In court filings, the resident said he had refrained from purchasing a firearm because he feared arrest, prosecution, incarceration or a fine. The lawsuit also argued that no state or federal process was available to remove the restriction based on the convictions, apart from an as-applied challenge under the Second Amendment.
“There is currently no mechanism available in New Hampshire or under federal law for Mr. Marshall to obtain relief from his federal disability, as a result of his conviction, absent a Second Amendment as-applied challenge.”
Lower court dismissal overturned
U.S. District Judge Paul J. Barbadoro dismissed the case in June 2025. The appeal challenged that ruling, and the First Circuit’s decision now returns the lawsuit to the lower court for further proceedings.
The appeal followed the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. That decision changed the framework courts use to assess Second Amendment restrictions by requiring the government to show that a firearm regulation is consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.
- The First Circuit vacated the district court’s dismissal.
- The federal firearm restriction remains the subject of the lawsuit.
- The case continues in federal district court after the appellate ruling.